BennyList
Best OverallBest overall โ free wishlist collection + name draw in one place
BennyList combines the name draw with shared wishlists, so participants can add items they actually want and their Santa can shop from a real list. Setup takes under two minutes: create the exchange, share a single link, and participants sign up to join. Available on iOS, Android, and as a browser extension.
Prefer a no-frills name draw? Try the free standalone Secret Santa tool โ
Pros
- Wishlists built in โ everyone shares what they want before the draw
- Invite via shareable link โ no need to collect everyone's email upfront
- Set a group budget visible to all participants
- iOS and Android apps + browser extension
- Free with no upsells or paywalls
Cons
- Newer platform โ smaller community than Elfster
Best for: Any group that wants wishlists + the draw in one place
Try BennyList Free